Advertorial Disclosure: We may earn money or products from the companies mentioned in this post.”
Part II: When Oil Isn’t the Answer (and Why One Reader’s Call Changed the Conversation)
I thought the first article would end the conversation.
Instead, it started one.
A reader called after finishing Hair Loss Doesn’t Start Where You Think It Does. She thanked me for putting words to something she had felt for years but couldn’t explain. Then she asked a very specific question:
“What’s the base in the scalp serum you recommend?”
I answered confidently.
“Oil.”
There was a pause on the line.
Then she said something that stopped me mid-sentence.
“Oh… I can’t do oils. They irritate my scalp.”
And just like that, a much bigger issue surfaced.
When “Oil” Became the Villain
Somewhere along the way, oil became synonymous with:
Greasy
Heavy
Pore-clogging
Irritating
For many people, especially those with sensitive scalps, that association didn’t come from nowhere. They tried oils before. Their scalp reacted. The itching, tingling, or inflammation followed. So they did what made sense.
They avoided oil altogether.
But here’s the truth most people never hear:
Oil itself isn’t the problem. Timing, formulation, and scalp condition are.
And sometimes, oil simply isn’t the right choice.
Oil-Based vs Water-Based: What No One Explains Clearly
This is where most hair loss conversations break down. People argue sides instead of explaining systems.
Let’s simplify it.
Oil-Based Scalp Serums
Oil-based products are designed to:
Sit on the scalp longer
Seal in moisture
Support dry, tight, or flaky scalps
Slow down moisture loss
They work best when the scalp barrier is compromised because of dryness.
But oils also:
Absorb slowly
Can feel heavy
Can trap heat
Can irritate already inflamed or reactive skin
If your scalp is sensitive, congested, or already inflamed, oil may feel like pouring gasoline on a smoldering fire.
Water-Based Scalp Treatments
Water-based products behave differently:
They absorb quickly
They feel lighter
They hydrate without coating
They calm rather than seal
These are often better for people who experience:
Tingling or burning with oils
Redness
Itching without visible flakes
Sensitivity that worsens with buildup
For those scalps, oil isn’t nourishment. It’s noise.
The Moment That Clicked for Both of Us
When I explained this to her, she said something that stuck with me:
“So it wasn’t that oil was bad. It was just wrong for my scalp.”
Exactly.
Hair loss doesn’t start with hair.
And scalp solutions don’t start with trends.
They start with listening to the body instead of forcing a product.
A Simple Self-Check Before You Choose a Scalp Product
Before buying anything, ask yourself:
You may respond better to an oil-based serum if:
Your scalp feels tight or dry
Flakes are visible and stubborn
Dryness worsens in colder months
Oils seem to disappear into your skin
You may respond better to a water-based formula if:
Oils cause itching or tingling
Your scalp feels irritated rather than dry
Buildup happens quickly
You’ve been told you have a “sensitive scalp”
This isn’t about good or bad products.
It’s about matching the formula to the condition.
Why This Matters More Than the Product Itself
Hair growth is not a surface-level issue.
If the scalp is irritated, inflamed, or overstimulated, the body does not prioritize growth. It prioritizes protection.
That’s why throwing stronger products at the problem rarely works.
The scalp doesn’t need pressure.
It needs permission.
The Real Lesson From That Call
That conversation reminded me why so many people feel stuck.
They aren’t ignoring their hair.
They’re ignoring their signals.
Oil isn’t wrong.
Water isn’t better.
The wrong match is the problem.
And hair loss rarely forgives mismatch.
Final Thought
If you read the first article and felt seen, but oils have never worked for you, this second part is your permission slip to stop forcing what doesn’t fit.
Sometimes progress doesn’t come from adding more.
It comes from choosing differently.
Hey Erro, it’s Donald Cooper living and retired. In Atlanta. Just relaxing and enjoying the fruits of my labor and traveling. You were running in my mind it take me a minute to remember your name haha. I see you’re still in the game selling products and teaching. I was notice a topic you posted about cosmetologist paying in on their taxes and Social Security. YES, I’ve been paying since day one each and every quarter. And saving for retirement also. One of best decisions I ever made. I’m well and hope you and your family are in good health and spirits.
Best regards
Hey Donald, great to hear from you! Yes, I always recognized you as a leader in financial literacy, you’ve inspire me through the years as you’ve always shared your experiences with me. I wrote that article as a heads up to others in the industry. The individual I referred to in the article, we both know, and trust me, it was a wake up call for me personally.
https://errolcrockett.com/why-beauty-entrepreneurs-must-pay-into-social-security/